by Broderick Perkins
(5/6/2011) Erate Exclusive - First it was mortgages, then credit cards and then the auto loan business.
Now, conducting business as usual, major banks continue to exhibit the
same kind of dirty tricks that ruined the housing market and brought the
economy to its knees.
This time, bankers are coming after your checking account as they
consistently violate federal regulations by failing to clearly and
comprehensively disclose mandated checking account information, a practice
that can expose you to hidden fees and dangerous risks.
Two recent studies chronicle the game of gotcha banks play with your
(Similar shenanigans have been found in the mortgage, credit card and auto loans businesses.)
Bigger Fees: A National Survey of Bank Fees and Fee Disclosure
Policies" by the U.S. Public Interest Research Group (PRIG), a
federation of state PRIGs.
Over the last six months, the U.S. PIRG staff conducted inquiries at 392
bank branches in 21 states and reviewed bank fees online in 12 others. It
had a tough time obtaining disclosures about fees.
Here's what it found.
In a finding virtually identical to those at the U.S. Government
Accountability Office (GAO), 23 percent of branches surveyed completely
refused to comply with researcher requests for fee schedules, required
disclosures by the Truth In Savings Act. Others provided often weighty piles
of useless other brochures.
Fewer than half (38 percent) of branches complied easily with the
simple researcher request for fee schedules. Only after two or more requests
did a total of 55 percent of branches provide fee schedules as requested and
as required by law.
U.S. PRIG says when banks don't fully disclose fees, consumers don't know
what their account will cost, they have a difficult time shopping around and
may end up with a checking account that's not a good fit for their budget.
"The Truth In Savings Act is a simple law that is supposed to help
consumers shop around," said Ed Mierzwinski, U.S. PIRG Consumer Program
Director and author of the report.
"But banks would rather hide the truth from consumers than give them
better information to help the market work. What do the banks have to hide?"
Despite the rough time banks gave U.S. PRIG about costs and fees, the
operation found free checking available at about 50 percent of the banks and
an additional 29 percent offered free checking with direct deposit.
Hidden Risks: The Case for Safe and
Transparent Checking Accounts, by Pew Charitable
Beginning in October 2010, Pew analyzed more than 250 types of checking
accounts offered online by the ten largest banks in the United States, which
hold nearly 60 percent of all deposit volume nationwide.
It identified patterns that impose unnecessary and potentially dangerous
risks on consumers.
Banks provide policies and fee information in a way that confuses
For example, the median length of checking account disclosures is 111
pages, twice as long as William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet. Also, the
ten largest banks use seven different terms to describe overdraft penalty fees making
it difficult for consumers to compare fees.
Pew developed a model disclosure form, similar to a nutrition label for
food or a Schumer Box for credit card offers to reveal how easy it is to
provide consumers with clear and consolidated information about the key
fees, terms and conditions of their checking account.
Researchers tested the disclosure box with consumers who said the box
would be a useful and valuable tool when opening an account.
Account holders are not provided full information about the
respective costs of overdraft options when considering opting-in to overdraft coverage, but bank
overdraft penalty fees, for example are disproportionate to the size of the
median overdraft amount.
For example, there are a median 49 different fees a customer could be
charged while using his or her checking account. If an overdraft was treated
like a short-term loan with a prepayment
period of seven days, the annual percentage rate for a typical incident
would be more than 5,000 percent.
Also, the median transaction amount that causes an overdraft is $36. The median overdraft penalty fee is
$35 and that could come with an overdraft transfer
fee at a median $10. Customers can be charged a median $140 a day in
Banks reserve the right to re-order transactions in a manner that
will maximize overdraft fees. For example, banks deposit funds only five days a week, but withdraw funds seven days a week.
aggressive marketing boosts overdraft opt-in fee collections
'Financial Literacy Month'… frugally
winning overdraft fee war, consumers losing billions
laws protect consumers from more credit card debt